Worldwide attitudes and perceptions regarding religion and faith in entertainment

The Global Faith & Entertainment Study Debuts at Variety's Spirituality & Faith in Entertainment Breakfast.

Introduction

The Global Faith and Entertainment Study is a first-of-its-kind global study, conducted by HarrisX in collaboration with the Faith & Media Initiative.

The study seeks to understand consumers’ and decisionmakers’ perspectives on how current entertainment media treats themes of faith, religion and spirituality in its narratives and characters, if there is a market for more accurate and diverse representation of faith, and what opportunities exist for improving these portrayals.

HarrisX surveyed nearly 10,000 entertainment consumers across 11 countries as well as 30 in-depth interviews with entertainment industry leaders.

Consumers say they learn about other religions through entertainment and see the potential for faith-inclusive content to create understanding and dialogue in society. Yet, respondents share that when they see their religion or faith - and others - included in mainstream entertainment, they feel it’s often sensationalized or that the portrayal leans on stereotypes.

Similarly, entertainment industry professionals also highlighted an opportunity to reach and connect with an underserved audience. They noted that producing this content not only represents a good business opportunity, but also provides the opportunity to demystify what consumers know about other faiths and create understanding between people of different belief systems.

Methodology

Online survey with global entertainment consumers

9,945

Online Interviews

Note: Online study only reaches populations with internet access. Limitations pronounced in some markets (e.g., India, Nigeria) .

Country
Breakdown
US
1,277
Canada
811
Mexico
809
Brazil
811
Italy
808
Germany
801
UK
1000
Turkey
806
India
1,205
Japan
805
Nigeria
812
Religion
Breakdown
Christian
4,827
Muslim
1,360
Hindu
992
Buddhist
305
Jewish
116
Other
360
Atheist
314
Agnostic
192
None
1,479
Age
Breakdown
18-24
13%
25-34
20%
35-44
19%
45-54
17%
55-64
13%
65+
18%
Gender
Breakdown
Male
50%
Female
50%
How
Professionally recruited. Online survey.

Languages
9 languages – English, Portuguese, Turkish, Hindi, Spanish, Italian, French, German, and Japanese.

Who
Adults who report consumption of entertainment media

Entertainment industry interviews

30+

In-depth Interviews

7+

Countries

Roles
Represented
Directors
Producers
Writers
Actors
Studio Executives
Industry professionals have worked in US, Spain, Italy, Canada, Mexico, Honduras, and Nigeria.

In-depth interviews are ongoing.

The Voice of Entertainment Consumers

Searching for positive spiritual content

A Spiritual World

73% of global respondents identify as religious, spiritual, or a person of faith.

Spiritual, religious, or a person of faith
None of the above

Categories created based on how many in each country identified as spiritual, religious, or a person of faith

High

n=3,634

Nigeria
96%
Brazil
95%
India
94%
Turkey
90%

Medium

n=3,705

U.S.
77%
Mexico
75%
Italy
72%
Canada
68%

Low

n=2,606

U.K.
51%
Germany
46%
Japan
28%
73%

Global average of people that identify as spiritual, religious, or a person of faith.

New Perspectives. We’ve updated our analytical lens from last year to focus on how much of the population identifies as non-secular, rather than how faithful each respondent is.

Source: “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
D4. Do you identify as any of the following?

Heavy Consumption

Over 50% watch TV or movies every day or almost every day

Same Storyline
Same Storyline

Watch TV or movies every day or almost everday

Japan
69%
Canada
61%
U.S.
61%
Italy
61%
Mexico
55%
U.K.
54%
Global
53%
Nigeria
47%
India
47%
Germany
45%
Turkey
43%
Brazil
37%

Source “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QE3: How often would you say you watch TV shows or movies?

The Problem

Current portrayals of religion and faith in entertainment are inadequate.

Religious Stereotypes

Globally, 63% said that entertainment perpetuates religious stereotypes.

Perpetuate stereotypes
Accurately portray

Entertainment perpetuating stereotypes versus accurately portraying religion

Countries by faithful categorization

High
56%
44%
Medium
68%
32%
Low
65%
35%
Canada
71%
29%
U.S.
69%
31%
Japan
67%
33%
Mexico
67%
33%
Turkey
67%
33%
U.K.
66%
34%
Italy
63%
37%
Global
63%
37%
Brazil
61%
39%
Germany
60%
40%
Nigeria
51%
49%
India
48%
52%

Source: “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QAccB2: Which of the following statements comes closest to your view?

One-Note Storylines

More people of each religion say current portrayals follow the same storyline over and over.

Same Storyline
Diverse Perspective

Religious portrayals: follow same storyline or diversity of stories

Portrayals
of…   
As viewed
by…
Christianity  
53%
47%
Christians
56%
44%
Entertainment consumers
Hinduism   
61%
39%
Hindus
54%
46%
Entertainment consumers
Buddhism    
63%
37%
Buddhists
55%
45%
Entertainment consumers
Judaism
53%
47%
Jews  
54%
46%
Entertainment consumers
Islam
59%
41%
Muslims  
56%
44%
Entertainment consumers
Atheism
52%
48%
Atheists/ Agnostics/None
51%
49%
Entertainment consumers

Source: “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QI5br: Would you say current portrayals of each of the following religions in entertainment follow the same storyline or perspective or is there diversity in the stories told about this religion?

The Solution

People want accurate representation of religion and faith in entertainment.

Accuracy is Crucial

80% say it is important that the entertainment industry improves their portrayals of faith to make them more accurate.

Important
Not important

Importance that entertainment industry makes portrayals of faith more accurate (top and bottom 2 Box)

Countries by faithful categorization

High
89%
11%
Medium
80%
20%
Low
67%
33%
Brazil
94%
06%
Nigeria
93%
07%
India
91%
09%
Mexico
82%
18%
U.S.
82%
18%
Global
80%
20%
Turkey
79%
21%
Canada
77%
23%
Italy
76%
24%
U.K.
74%
26%
Japan
66%
34%
Germany
59%
41%

Source “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QNEED: How important or unimportant is it that the entertainment industry improves their portrayals of faith to make them more accurate?

Consumers Want Diversity

68% of global viewers want more diverse perspectives about various faiths.

Important
Not important

Importance of diverse religious perspective coverage in TV and movies (top and bottom 2 Box)

Countries by faithful categorization

High
82%
18%
Medium
67%
33%
Low
49%
51%
Brazil
91%
09%
Italy
84%
16%
Nigeria
83%
17%
India
79%
21%
Turkey
69%
31%
Global
68%
32%
Mexico
67%
33%
U.S.
66%
34%
U.K.
62%
38%
Canada
59%
41%
Germany
49%
51%
Japan
33%
67%

Source “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QAccD: How important or unimportant is it to you that television and movies cover diverse perspectives on different religions?

Insight & Understanding

59% globally, reported that entertainment taught them something they didn’t know about other religions.

Learned something
Neither agree nor disagree
Didn't learn anything

Learned something they didn’t know about another religion after seeing it in a movie/show

Countries by faithful categorization

High
73%
16%
11%
Medium
56%
24%
20%
Low
46%
27%
27%
Nigeria
83%
08%
09%
India
75%
18%
07%
Brazil
71%
16%
13%
Mexico
64%
21%
15%
Turkey
60%
24%
16%
Global
59%
22%
18%
U.S.
55%
24%
21%
Canada
54%
26%
20%
Italy
51%
27%
22%
U.K.
49%
26%
25%
Japan
44%
30%
26%
Germany
44%
27%
29%

Source “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QI10r1: I have learned something I didn't know before about another religion after seeing it in a movie/show - Please let us know if you agree or disagree with each of the following statements about faith in entertainment media.

Opportunity for Understanding

The top reasons people care about representation are to create understanding between people of different beliefs, dispel stereotypes and prejudices, and improve their ability to freely practice and express their beliefs. Respondents in all countries agree that accurate portrayal of religion is crucial to foster global understanding.

It is crucial to portray faith/religion accurately to promote understanding and respect for diverse beliefs concerning faith/religion.
Accurate portrayals of faith/religion in movies and TV are important, but ultimately do not impact how people view faith/interact with others with different beliefs.
Writers, producers, and directors should have artistic freedom to portray faith/religion as they see fit, even if it includes negative perspectives on a faith/religion.
I don't have a strong opinion

Views about impact of representations of faith/religion in movies and TV

Global
42%
25%
16%
17%

Countries by faithful categorization

High
53%
24%
15%
08%
Medium
40%
24%
18%
18%
Low
30%
27%
15%
28%

Source“The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QI12: Which of the following statements best represents your own point of view about representations of faith/religion in movies and TV?

Positive Themes

Viewers desire more positive themes – friendship, nature, family, inspiration, and faith. And they want fewer negative themes – power, war, and conflict.

Most present and most desired themes in TV/movies

Themes most present

01.
02.
03.
04.
05.
06.
07.
08.
09.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.

Family
Friendship
Conflict
Power
Nature
The supernatural
War
Inspiration
Tradition
Morality
Politics
Environment
Faith & Religion
Work
Spirituality
The afterlife
Redemption
Ritual

Themes most desired

01.
02.
03.
04.
05.
06.
07.
08.
09.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.

Friendship
Nature
Family
Inspiration
Environment
Faith & Religion
Morality
Tradition
The supernatural
Spirituality
The afterlife
Politics
Power
War
Redemption
Conflict
Work
Ritual

Source Source: “The Global Faith and Entertainment Study” by HarrisX (The Faith and Media Initiative commissioned a global online survey of among 9,945 adults in 11 countries), Jul 26 – Aug 22, 2023.
QE10. From the list below, please select which themes are most often present in the TV/movies you watch?
QE11. Which themes do you not see enough of in the TV/movies you watch that you want to see more of?

The Media
Point-of-View

In-depth interviews with leading directors, producers, writers, actors, studio executives surfaced some important trends and insights about faith’s place in the entertainment landscape.

Sidelined Out of Fear

Religion is seen as a controversial, niche topic with a finite audience, so it’s often sidelined out of fear of offending and fear of financial failure.

Everyone is afraid of offending, so you end up getting systems that homogenize everything out of fear.”

Director, Producer

Statistically [religion] is probably underrepresented…if you make a pure statistical analysis to see how much gender, sexual orientation represented. Hollywood is cautious, and they do a pretty good job. In terms of religion, I think is not very much a topic they think of because unconsciously…they prefer to avoid potentially controversial topics.”

CEO

One-Note Narratives

Hollywood often represents its decision makers, and often relies on sticky stereotypes as narrative devices. Content, therefore, often gives a one-dimensional view of faith and religion. This sentiment was echoed by entertainment consumers who said current portrayals follow the same story line over and over.

“I think that people want to impress a very, very, very unique culture in L.A. And oftentimes, that's at odds with really entertaining Middle America.

Director, Producer

Understanding

Decision makers see the power entertainment has to create understanding.

“We don’t want to create stories that are going to separate us more. We need to tell stories that bring us together.”

Producer, Co-Founder, CEO

Unrealized Potential

Hollywood, as an industry, does not recognize the untapped market for spiritual content.

“I think it creates a large audience that feels under seen, and under celebrated, which I think on the one hand is a business opportunity. But I also think it’s a moral obligation to represent society.”

Director, Producer

“There’s going to be a market for films that are uplifting and show the values of all the faiths…I think there’s a lot of people like me, that want to see films that show love and kindness and mercy and compassion.”

Executive Producer, Founder

Spiritual Representation

Despite fear in the industry, many creators acknowledge that audiences crave positivity, spirituality, and stories that bind, not separate. They’re interested in telling more stories about different people, cultures, and beliefs.

“I think there's going to be a market for films that are uplifting and show the values of all the faiths…”

Executive Producer, Founder

“There’s this middle space of values, and things that we all celebrate. And I think that there’s an incredible hunger for that type of content right now.”

Director, Producer

A
Way
Forward

There is an opportunity for the entertainment industry to attract a large global audience by creating content that has thought provoking, diverse, and accurate portrayals of characters’ faith and spirituality.

Both from the consumer point of view and within the entertainment industry itself, there is a desire to tell stores that reflect and reveal a range of lived faith experiences and values. Not only do these opportunities signify a means to improve the bottom line, but audiences also believe that improving representation of faith and religion has the potential to bring society closer together.

Proven financial success will be a key factor that helps bring about change within the industry.

Downloads

Download the complete report, including social media assets.

Download Full Report